Sponsered By:

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Why Srikrishna Committee thinks Telangana is NOT Backward?

Telangana 73: Are we condemned to repeat history?

The authors of Indian constitution, unlike the current generation of Indians, did not believe that the states, districts and mandals within India are static, unchanging, and permanent.  They had the maturity to accept that states would evolve and change, and hence made provisions for creation of new states in Indian Union.

Indian Constitution

Article 3 of Indian Constitution addresses the topic of ‘Formation of new States and alteration of areas, boundaries or names of existing States’.  It says:

Parliament may by law
(a) form a new State by separation of territory from any State or by uniting two or more States or parts of States or by uniting any territory to a part of any State;
(b) increase the area of any State;
(c) diminish the area of any State;
(d) alter the boundaries of any State;
(e) alter the name of any State; Provided that no Bill for the purpose shall be introduced in either House of Parliament except on the recommendation of the President and unless, where the proposal contained in the Bill affects the area, boundaries or name of any of the States, the Bill has been referred by the President to the Legislature of that State for expressing its views thereon within such period as may be specified in the reference or within such further period as the President may allow and the period so specified or allowed has expired Explanation I In this article, in clauses (a) to (e), State includes a Union territory, but in the proviso, State does not include a Union territory Explanation II The power conferred on Parliament by clause (a) includes the power to form a new State or Union territory by uniting a part of any State or Union territory to any other State or Union territory
The steps for creating a new state are as follows: A bill on a new state has to be recommended by the President.  In India it is usually the Cabinet which requests the President to do that.  Article 3 makes it clear that the Parliament is the sole authority on making a decision on a new state.  President refers the bill to the State Assembly for its views giving it a certain period of time.   Parliament is not obligated to follow on the views of State Assembly.  If the State Assembly does not express its opinion within the specified period of time, the bill could be introduced in the Parliament after the expiry of the specified period.  

Why did the authors of the constitution put complete responsibility of creating new states ONLY with the Parliament?  Why did they not provide a bigger role for a State Assembly other than expressing ‘its views’ on the topic? 

To understand the intentions behind a certain clause in our Constitution the legal experts refer to the discussions of the authors that preceded the formulation of these clauses referred to as Constituent Assembly Debates (CAD).   One legal expertclarifies:

When the Constituent Assembly was deliberating in November 1948 on the scope and content of Article 3, there was a proposal by Prof. KT Shah that the legislation constituting a new State from any region of a State should originate from the legislature of the State concerned. Had this procedure been approved, the power to decide the statehood of a region seeking separation would have been vested with the State legislature dominated by the elite of developed regions.

Opposing the same and using the then demand for an Andhra Province as an example, Shri K Santhanam stated as under: “I wonder whether Professor Shah fully realises the implications of his amendment. If his amendment is adopted, it would mean that no minority in any State can ask for separation of territory… unless it can get a majority in that State legislature.

Take the case of Madras Province for instance. The Andhras want separation. They bring up a resolution in the Madras Legislature.  It is defeated by a majority. There ends the matter. The way of the Andhras is blocked altogether. They cannot take any further step to constitute an Andhra province."  Thus Article 3 emerged in its current form.

It is the Constitutional intent that the will of the people of a region to form a separate State be the sole criterion for the Centre to initiate the process of State formation. This is the Constitutional benchmark for creating a new State for a region, as amply demonstrated in the deliberations of the Constituent Assembly and as reflected in the current phraseology of Article 3 of the Constitution of India.

This interpretation of Article 3 prevailed over creation of many new states in modern India thereby nearly doubling the number of states in the last fifty years.  If not for this interpretation, Andhra State would never have formed.  If India had not honored the ‘will of the people of a region to form a separate state’, there wouldn’t have been states like Mizoram, Nagaland, and Tripura, some of them composed of only two districts.

Supreme Court Verdict

A constitutional democracy also refers to legal verdicts which decide on the interpretation and set a precedent on applicability of a certain clause from Indian constitution. 

Back in 1960 a Bill was introduced in the Indian Parliament proposing the formation of Maharashtra and Gujarat. This Bill was referred by the President to the State Assembly to obtain their views.  Upon receiving the views, the Bill was passed in the Parliament.  A petition was filed against this by Babulal Parante in High Court of Bombay: 

His contention was that the said Act was passed in contravention of the provisions of Art. 3 of the Constitution, since the Legislature of Bombay had not been given an opportunity of expressing its views on the formation of the composite State.  The High Court dismissed the petition.

In this case, Babulal Parante v. State of Bombay, 1960 AIR 51, 1960 SCR (1) 605, the court explains the provisions of Article 3:

The period within which the State Legislature must express its views has to be specified by the President; but the President may extend the period so specified. If, however, the period specified or extended expires and no views of the State Legislature are received, the second condition laid down in the proviso is fulfilled in spite of the fact that the views of the State Legislature have not been expressed.

The intention seems to be to give an opportunity to the State Legislature to express its views within the time allowed; if the State Legislature fails to avail itself of that opportunity, such failure does not invalidate the introduction of the Bill.

Nor is there anything in the proviso to indicate that Parliament must accept or act upon the views of the State Legislature.

Clearly, Indian Constitution envisioned a situation where a state may refuse to provide its view or provide negative views about a formation of a new state, and therefore gave full powers to Indian Parliament to go ahead with its decisions irrespective of opposition from the State Assembly. 

Case of Telangana

Telangana region consisting of 10 districts was always a strong contender for a separate state from the beginning.  Even in 1956, there were strong indications that it would remain a separate state.  However, bowing to the pressure of the prevailing sentiments of that time it was merged with Andhra State to form Andhra Pradesh.  To allay the apprehensions of Telangana people, India gave this region and its people certain ‘constitutional guarantees’ protected by a ‘regional standing committee’.  All of these experiments stand failed.  Telangana has erupted in a violent agitation in 1969 to be brutally suppressed.  Telangana then rose in a long and sustained agitation of the last fifteen years.

On 9 Dec 2009, in one pithy statement, Home Minister of Indian Union, P Chidambaram, announced the steps towards formation of a new state in India called Telangana:

“The process of forming the state of Telangana will be initiated.”

It was one of the most ecstatic moments for people of Telangana rivaling the last one which came on 17 September 1948 when Indian forces liberated Hyderabad State from Nizam’s rule. People came out onto the streets, danced and celebrated through the night.  The next day, the national and international newspapers ran the news that India gets a new state.  Unlike in some democracies countries, Indian leaders have a habit of going back on their words.  Little did people of Telangana realize, little did news channels realize, little did international media realize, and little did P Chidambaram himself realize, the catch was in the very next statement! 

“An appropriate resolution will be moved in the Assembly.”

With the first sentence the Home Minister of India heralded a new chapter for 35 Million of Telangana supposedly ending a 54 year old struggle, and with the very next sentence he put hard brakes on that new chapter. 

Instead of creating the bill for Telangana at the center, in a clear breach of the procedures proposed by Indian Constitution, he referred it directly to State Assembly.  It is unfortunate that Honorable Home Minister of India did not do his homework before referring the fate of Telangana back to the State Assembly.  If he had followed the proper procedure as prescribed by Indian Constitution, this region would have been spared of so much agony, frustrations, agitations, protests, and also would have avoided nearly 350 suicides of young students. 

Immediately after the historic December 9th statement, a series of egregious events unfolded in the State of Andhra Pradesh.  Political leaders from Coastal Andhra and Rayalaseema resigned en masse to adjourn the State Assembly so that no resolution on Telangana could take place.  This is the third time that the majority Seemandhra region has resorted to such a tactic to subdue and suppress the interests of minority Telangana region.  It is ironic that the rationale for creating Article 3 in the current form stemmed from fulfilling aspirations of Andhras to form their own state, but it is now being denied by the same region to people of Telangana.   

It is clear that P Chidambaram did not follow the correct procedure.  The Indian Cabinet should have created the Bill at the Center and asked the President to refer it to the Andhra Pradesh State Assembly specifying a deadline for expressing its views.  If the State Assembly did not respond in time, it could still introduce it in the Parliament. 

Instead of realizing his folly, the Home Minister of India reversed his Dec 9th decision and rolled back his plans for separate Telangana, thereby rewarding the majority region of Seemandhra for their unconstitutional tactic, thereby undermining the very basis on which Article 3 was created.  On 23 Dec 2009, in a blatant volte face of this previous statement, P Chidambaram said:

“However, after the (Dec 9th) statement, the situation in Andhra Pradesh has altered. A large number of political parties are divided on the issue.”

“There is a need to hold wide ranging consultations with all political parties and groups in the state. Government of India will take steps to involve all concerned in the process,” he said indicating that the process for evolving all-party consensus over Telangana will have to be undertaken afresh.

Though there is a clear divide within each political party along the regional lines, P Chidambaram expects all political parties within the state to reach a consensus on such a contentious issue, without realizing that Indian Constitution does not recognize political parties as legal representatives of people.  Only elected leaders are true representatives of its people.  And it is clear that most of the leaders of this region, irrespective of their political affiliation, are in support of separate Telangana. 

An all-party consensus is not possible in any democracy.  Many bills have been passed in the Parliament though some of the political parties opposed it.   Such an expectation, to get an all-party consensus in the matters of creation of states, shows political immaturity emanating from Indian Cabinet.

Step forward

Indian Government should accept that it has made a mistake in referring the issue of Telangana to Andhra Pradesh State Assembly.  Now, it has to create a Bill for Telangana solely on the basis of will of the people of the region to form a state, as seen clearly from massive agitations and protests across the region, and evident from the support from elected leaders of the region irrespective of their political affiliation.  President of India could then refer the Bill to Andhra Pradesh State Assembly for its views clearly specifying a deadline.  If the State of Andhra Pradesh fails to comply or even votes negatively on the Bill, the President of India should still go ahead and introduce it in the Parliament understanding that Article 3 was created to protect the will of smaller region from being suppressed by majority region.

Fuel Price Hike

Few days ago, the UPA government, led by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh,announced a steep hike in the fuel prices across the country.
Last night, I was discussing with two individuals who thought this increase was atrocious. I explained that this fuel hike was long overdue, that the prices of oil in the world are shooting up like crazy, and that almost every other country has already increased the prices, and that India had withheld this hike for quite long time. I told them it was inevitable – it had to be done some day. Those individuals expressed surprise and asked how come they don’t get to hear this from the TV and media. (I guess they were just watching the wrong channels).
TOI is Irresponsible
Next day, in the morning, I got to read THE HINDU and TIMES OF INDIA. While THE HINDU did mention that the prices of oil have been skyrocketing in the world market and hence has influenced the current hike, TOI has failed to mention even once that this price hike was due to those reasons.
It is the role of the media to educate its masses and present the facts. They could interpret the story in their own way if they want to, but to deliberately omit and hide some extremely important facts is almost like fabrication of a lie when done by a media agency which has such a wide circulation. In a democracy, media plays a great role and forms a pillar along with legislature, executive and judiciary. While TOI wants to enjoy all the fundamental rights, including posting one semi-nude picture everyday in its SPORTS section where most impressionable young ones usually turn to, it seems to shirk all its duties to present the facts. TOI is an extremely irresponsible media agency.
The TV channels are no less irresponsible. All you see is a bunch of young chest beating journalists trying desperately to thump themselves harder just to climb the corporate ladder. They always seem to pant as if they just ran a marathon.

Swiss banks: WikiLeaks unlikely to release data soon

LONDON: WikiLeaks is unlikely anytime soon to make public material provided to it this week by Swiss bank whistleblower Rudolf Elmer , according to WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange and sources close to Elmer. 

At a London news conference on Monday, Elmer, former chief of the office of the Julius Baer Bank in the Cayman Islands, handed to Assange what he said were two discs containing information on about 2,000 offshore banking clients. 

Assange said WikiLeaks would treat the information provided by Elmer like "all other information" the website received, which would include public revelations. However, he said, before any of the material is released, "it could be weeks. It could be longer." 

Assange indicated WikiLeaks and possibly media organizations would review Elmer's material before making it public. He said this would take at least "a couple of weeks." 

Two sources familiar with the material said it was dense and not self-explanatory. One of the sources said the material contained a handful of names that might be recognizable. 

Even in cases where names seemed familiar, the source said, there is no way to be sure from the material supplied to WikiLeaks of the identities of account holders and further investigation would have to be done to confirm the account holders' identity. 

Jack Blum, a former Congressional investigator and Washington lawyer who has been advising Elmer, said Elmer would not be releasing any names or corporate names from the data cache because the account data outlined financial "structures" which are "difficult to figure out what is going on." 

Blum also cautioned that even if account holders' identities can be confirmed, this does not constitute evidence that such people are engaged in offshore tax evasion. 

Blum said government investigators would be in the best position to confirm the identities of people involved in transactions documented by Elmer's material. 

Sources close to Elmer said some, if not most, of the material in his cache had been made available to government investigators in countries whose identities remain unknown. 

Assange said WikiLeaks might hand over some of the material to Britain's Serious Fraud Office. 

Elmer, who was fired by Julius Baer in 2002, is due to go on trial in Switzerland on Wednesday for breaching bank secrecy. The bank has accused Elmer of pursuing a vendetta against the company. 

Elmer and his lawyer maintain the Swiss prosecution is unfair because the material he allegedly leaked -- including some material on alleged offshore tax evasion abuses published by WikiLeaks -- originated in the Cayman Islands, where Swiss authorities arguably lack jurisdiction. 

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

Man Rescued After 16 Hours Buried Under Mud

A Brazilian man has had a remarkable escape after being buried in mudslides under his house for 16 hours.

Union Cabinet reshuffle today, new faces likely

New Delhi, Jan 19 (IANS) In the first-ever reshuffle of the 19-month-old United Progressive Alliance (UPA)-II government scheduled for today, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh is likely to induct some new faces and send out some Congress ministers for party work.

The oaths of office and secrecy would be administered to the new ministers at 5 p.m. at the Rashtrapati Bhavan, official sources told IANS.

However, the official notification and invitation for the function is yet to be issued, the sources added.

Congress president Sonia Gandhi Tuesday met Prime Minister Manmohan Singh for nearly two hours to finalise the reshuffle of the union council of ministers.

How key ministries have performed in UPA-II

While there were different versions in the political circles about the nature of the reshuffle, it was clear that the 'big four' in the cabinet - Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee, Defence Minister A.K. Antony, Home Minister P. Chidmabaram and External Affairs Minister S.M. Krishna - will retain their portfolios.

The sources said that while DMK is likely to get a berth in place of former communications minister A. Raja, Trinamool Congress is also expected to get an additional ministership.

While Sharad Pawar's portfolios of agriculture and food, consumer affairs and public distribution are likely to be split, the party may be compensated either by elevation of Minister of State for Civil Aviation (Independent Charge) Praful Patel to the cabinet or allotment of another portfolio.

Minority Affairs Minister and former Uttar Pradesh Congress chief Salman Khurshid's elevation to cabinet rank appears almost certain as the party prepares to woo larger sections in the most populous state which goes to polls in 2012.

Khurshid may be given law portfolio with M. Veerappa Moily shifted to human resource development which is currently with Kapil Sibal, who also holds the communications and science and technology portfolio.

From West Bengal, which goes to polls in May, Trinamool Congress leader Sudip Bandyopadhyay is likely to be inducted.

From Kerala, K.C. Venugopal may find a place in the ministry. Venugopal is seen as a replacement from the Nair community for Shashi Tharoor, who had to resign last year in the wake of Kochi-Indian Premier League row.

From the DMK, the choice may be between former ministers T.R.Baalu or T.K.S. Elangovan.

From the agitation-hit Telangana region, former Andhra Pradesh Congress chief Keshava Rao may be inducted.

Among the other names doing the rounds are Congress spokespersons Manish Tewari and Jayanthi Natarajan, party's chief whip in Lok Sabha Paban Singh Ghatowar and former minister Suresh Pachouri.

If there is a major reshuffle, several ministers including Kantilal Bhuria, Virbhadra Singh, B.K. Handique and Vilasrao Deshmukh may be drafted for party work. Sports Minister M.S. Gill may also be shifted.

Today's induction of new ministers will be followed by a reshuffle of portfolios.

The cabinet reshuffle will be followed by the constitution of a new Congress Working Committee which will include many of the ministers moved out.

wallpapers.












Monday, January 10, 2011

Telugu Movie Premakavali Songs MP3 2011 HQ


Telugu Movie Premakavali Songs
Starring : Aadi, Isha Chawla, Dev Gill
Director: K.Vijaya Bhaskar
Producer: K.Atchi Reddy
Music Director: Anoop Rubens 
Lyrics : Ananth Sriram, Bhuvara Chandra, Sahith, Ramajogayya Shastry
Cassettes and CDs : Aditya Music

╬ Click On Links Below To Download Prema Kavali Songs ╬

Song 01 - Dum Dum Dum – Benny Dayal

Song 02 - Chirunavve – Vijay Prakash

Song 03 - Tholakari Chinukai – Ranjith, Shreya Ghoshal

Song 04 - Listen To My Heart – Anju, Anjana Sowmya

Song 05 - Manasantha – KK

Song 06 - Nuvve Nuvve – Chitra, Vijay Prakash

Song 07 - Chirunavve (Remix) – Vijay Prakash




Download Telugu Movie Prema Kavali Songs MP3 2011,premakavali songs download,download mp3 premakavali,prema kavali songs free download,Telugu Songs

Telugu Movie Wanted Songs 2011 MP3 HQ


Telugu Movie Wanted Songs MP3 2011
Banner : Bhavya Creations
Cast : Gopichand, Deeksha Seth, Prakash Raj and others
Music Director : Chakri
Cinematography : Rasool Ellore
Producer : Anand Prasad
Director : B V S Ravi
Cassettes and CDs : Aditya Music

Click On Links Below To Download Wanted 2011 Songs :-

Song 01.Arakilo Pogaru : Ranjith - Lyrics : Bhaskar Batla

Song 02.Yevo Pichi Veshalu : Javed Ali - Lyrics : Bhaskar Batla

Song 03.Dil Mera Dhak Dhak : Udit Narayan, Smita - Lyrics : Bhaskar Batla

Song 04.Cheppana Cheppana : Chakri, Kousalya - Lyrics : Bhaskar Batla

Song 05.A For Angel : Krishna Chaitanya, MM. Srilekha - Lyrics : Bhaskar Batla





Telugu Movie Wanted Songs 2011 MP3 HQ,gopichand wanted songs,wanted 2011 songs download,download mp3 wanted telugu 2011,Telugu Songs